Provenance Research And Potential Restitution

Handling colonial cultural goods: Baden-Württemberg's approach

Baden-Württemberg acknowledges its historical responsibility and is committed to provenance research in order to identify and return colonial cultural goods that were acquired unlawfully.

Berechne Lesezeit
  • Teilen
Ministerin Petra Olschowski und weitere Akteure mit der Elfenbeinmaske der Königsmutter

Until the 20th century, many cultural goods were brought to Europe from colonial contexts. This was often done by force, through military action or on behalf of museums and university collections. Baden-Württemberg is leading the way in coming to terms with the colonial era and its consequences. The possible restitution of cultural goods and human remains from colonial contexts is embedded in an overall strategy involving museums, universities, archives and the communities of origin - this is the Baden-Württemberg approach.

Petra Olschowski, Minister of Science, Research and Arts: "The question of how we handle cultural goods and other objects in our collections that were acquired in a colonial context is increasingly being discussed - far beyond the museums. The topic is also gaining relevance in society, as coming to terms with the past is always the starting point for understanding the present. Baden-Württemberg is fulfilling its historical responsibility in this regard."

Transparency and openness are of crucial importance when engaging with colonial legacies. This means: well-processed and curated collections that also provide information about the objects' origins and a possible colonial context. For this reason, the collections in Baden-Württemberg's museums and universities are being systematically processed and the results made available online. This is the starting point for further dialogue and cooperation - especially with the communities and countries of origin.

„We are continuing our systematic scientific research into the provenance of our museum and scientific collections and are disclosing this transparently. The focus here is on provenance research relating to Nazi-looted property and objects acquired in a colonial context of injustice. This may result in the return of relevant objects.“
Baden-Württemberg coalition agreement

Restitutions that have already been carried out

Die ehemalige Wissenschaftsministerin gibt die Witboii-Bibel und -Peitsche in Namibia zurück

Return of the Witbooi Bible and whip

At the beginning of 2019, Baden-Württemberg returned the Bible and whip of the important Nama Kaptein and fighter against colonialism, Hendrik Witbooi, to Namibia. Both artifacts were looted by German troops in 1893; they were last kept in the Linden Museum in Stuttgart. Together with a delegation of around 20 individuals from the fields of science, culture and politics, the then Minister of Science Theresia Bauer and State Secretary Petra Olschowski travelled to the country of origin to return both objects in person. The ceremony was attended by around 3,000 people, including the founding president of Namibia, members of the government and members of the Witbooi family. Acting President Hage Geingob accepted the Bible and whip.

This restitution laid the foundation for the Baden-Württemberg approach: restitution is the starting point for a dialogue and equal partnerships with the communities and countries of origin. The Namibia Initiative was launched on the occasion of this restitution. The aim is to shape the reconciliation process together with Namibian partners through exchange and joint projects in science and art. Over 30 institutions in Namibia and Baden-Württemberg are part of the initiative.

Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Restitution in Namibia)

Uebergabe der Benin-Bronzen an Nigeria

Benin bronzes: restitution in Nigeria

In summer 2021, Baden-Württemberg was the first federal state in Germany to lay the foundations for the restitution of the so-called Benin bronzes. In December 2022, a restitution agreement was concluded with the Nigerian National Commission for Museums and Monuments (NCMM). In this agreement, ownership of all Benin bronzes in the Linden-Museum Stuttgart was transferred to Nigeria. However, 24 of the 70 objects will remain in the Linden-Museum on loan for an initial period of ten years.

The 16th century ivory mask of Queen Mother (Iyoba) Idia was handed over to the Director General of the NCMM at a ceremony. Science Minister Petra Olschowski accompanied the former Federal Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock and the then Federal Government Commissioner for Culture and the Media Claudia Roth to Nigeria to hand over the mask of Iyoba Idia and other Benin bronzes to the partners in Nigeria.

Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Restitution der Bronzen)

Restitution of ancestral remains

Übergabe der human remains an die Marshallinseln
Rückgabe sterblicher Überreste der Maori an die Neuseeländischen Nachfahren im Lindenmuseum
Feierliche Rückgebezeremonie von menschlichen Überresten an Hawaii
Rückgabe strebliche Überreste Australien

The restitution of ancestral remains taken from colonial contexts carries a specific ethical obligation, as these consist of bones, skulls and skeletons of deceased individuals. Ancestral remains were often looted by force, in a fundamentally unethical manner, and brought to Europe. This was almost always done without the consent of themselves and of their relatives.

The restitution of human remains - in close consultation with representatives of the communities of origin - is a high priority for Baden-Württemberg. In doing so, the state is acting in accordance with the Framework Principles for Dealing with Collections from Colonial Contexts, which were adopted by the federal and state governments and the municipal umbrella organisations in 2019. The Framework Principles include the obligation to restitute ancestral remains unconditionally.

So far, ancestral remains have been restituted to delegations from Australia, New Zealand, Hawai’i and Marshall Islands.

Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Hawaii)
Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Neuseeland)
Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Australien)
Pressemitteilung (Press release DE) (Marshallinseln)

Pressemitteilungen zum Thema

Wissenschaftsministerin Petra Olschowski unterschreibt bei der feierlichen Rückgabezeremonie den Vertrag mit Neuseeland
Kunst und Kultur

Land gibt menschliche Überreste an Māori Community aus Neuseeland zurück

Symbolbild
Kunst und Kultur

Land gibt menschliche Überreste indigener Hawaiianerinnen und Hawaiianer zurück

Kunstministerin Petra Olschowski mit der Elfenbeinmaske der Königinmutter Idia
Kunst und Kultur

Rückgabe von Benin-Objekten an Nigeria

Übergabe der Elfenbeinmaske der Königinmutter Idia an die Vertreter Nigerias
Kunst und Kultur

70 Benin-Objekte aus der Sammlung des Linden-Museums an Nigeria übertragen

Drei ausgestellte Benin-Bronzen
Kunst und Kultur

Benin-Bronzen: Land überträgt Eigentum an Nigeria

Benin-Bronzen
Kunst und Kultur

Umgang mit Benin-Bronzen: Bund, Länder und Museen einigen sich auf gemeinsames Vorgehen

Benin-Bronzen
Kunst und Kultur

Umgang mit Benin-Bronzen: Land fasst Grundsatzbeschluss

Dummy Image
Kunst und Kultur

Erste Kulturministerkonferenz / Ministerin Bauer zu Eckpunkten zum Umgang mit kolonialem Erbe

Benin-Bronzen
Kunst und Kultur

Benin-Bronzen: Deutschland sollte starkes Signal setzen

Benin Bronzen
Kunst und Kultur

Mehr Transparenz: Umgang mit Benin-Bronzen

Kunst und Kultur

Koloniales Erbe: Land unterstützt kommunale Museen bei Aufarbeitung

Shawn van Eeden
Kunst und Kultur

Land verstärkt Aufarbeitung von kolonialem Erbe in Museen und Hochschulen / Konferenz "Das neue Museum"

© Linden-Museum Stuttgart, Dominik Drasdow
Kunst und Kultur

Baden-Württemberg bringt Witbooi-Bibel und Peitsche zurück nach Namibia

© Linden-Museum Stuttgart, Dominik Drasdow
Kunst und Kultur

 Land gibt „Witbooi-Bibel“ und Peitsche an Namibia zurück

Kunst und Kultur

Bilanz Delegationsreise nach Namibia / Start gemeinsamer Projekte